The Chip-for-Minerals Bargain Is Decaying One Side at a Time
The chip half of the 2025 China bargain is eroding quickly inside China's own market, while the mineral half cannot be replaced for years.
In July 2025 the Trump administration reversed its ban on Nvidia's H20 chip, and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said on the record what the reversal was for. [1]
You want to sell the Chinese enough that their developers get addicted to the American technology stack. — Howard Lutnick
One trade, two halves, priced in public the same day: licensed silicon going east, minerals coming west. Lutnick had a theory for why the chip half was safe to sell. [2] Keep the buyer dependent on the American stack, he reasoned, while holding back the top of the line.
We won't sell them our best, not our second best, not even our third best. — Howard Lutnick
Sixteen months later, that premise has come apart — but on only one side of the bargain, and at a speed the other side cannot match. The two halves of the exchange were always running on different clocks. The chip half lives inside a market that already exists, and its erosion has come from inside that market. Huawei has shipped more than 100 million devices on its homegrown Kirin processors since 2023. [3] In February, DeepSeek excluded Nvidia and AMD from optimization of its flagship V4 model and gave Huawei a head start of several weeks. [4] By the first half of this year, Nvidia's share of China's data-center chip market had fallen to 34 percent. [3] The licensed channel shows the same thing from the other end. Roughly 600,000 Nvidia H200s sit stranded in Hong Kong because Beijing has withheld import approvals, letting the chips through only in small batches while steering buyers toward domestic processors. [5] Nvidia's own account is blunt.
despite receiving some licenses, we have since stopped shipping H200s to China — Nvidia Inc.
A compliant lane still moves. Alibaba, ByteDance, and Tencent ordered more than three million export-compliant RTX Pro 5500 cards worth more than $35 billion. [5] But that lane sells a lesser product — and with the H200s stopped, it is now all Nvidia itself ships to China. The mineral half runs on the other clock. Replacing Chinese rare earths is not a matter of switching suppliers inside an existing market; it means building mines and refineries that do not yet exist. Beijing halted yttrium shipments for months, stopping production lines across American semiconductors, energy, and aerospace, and has since allowed only sporadic deliveries, usually after White House interventions. [6] Experts cited in September put any Western replacement years out, through at least 2030. [6] The supply-chain diversification the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission now formally recommends runs on precisely this clock, the one that cannot be hurried. [7] That is the whole mechanism, and it is simple. Chips are substituted inside a market that already exists, in product cycles measured in months. Minerals require mines and refineries that do not yet exist, and are replaced in years. On one clock, China's dependence on American silicon shrinks quarter by quarter. On the other, America's dependence on Chinese minerals has not begun to shrink in any way that matters. None of this means the bargain is dead. It means it will have to be struck again, and not at the old price. The rare-earth multiples were already squeezing American and Japanese manufacturers ahead of the last Trump-Xi meeting. [8] Between signatures, one half of the deal has kept losing its buyer while the other has kept gaining scarcity. Washington's half was worth a captive market in July 2025; that market has spent sixteen months walking away. Beijing's half was worth reopening the supply line; it has only grown scarcer since. The next signature will be asked to pay for both changes at once.
- 1. Trump Administration Allows Nvidia to Resume AI Chip Sales to China
- 2. Nvidia Condemns $1 Billion AI Chip Smuggling into China
- 3. China Advances AI Chips Despite U.S. Export Controls
- 4. DeepSeek Excludes US Chipmakers From V4 Model Optimization
- 5. China Blocks 600,000 Nvidia H200 Chips in Hong Kong
- 6. China Uses Rare Earth Export Controls to Pressure United States
- 7. USCC Warns China Uses Diplomacy to Mask Strategic Competition
- 8. China Export Curbs Drive Global Rare-Earth Price Spikes