Fort Erie Mayor Uses Strong-Mayor Powers to Fire CAO
Mayor Tom Insinna dismissed Chief Administrative Officer Chris McQueen without cause and plans to appoint Krystle Caputo as the replacement.
Fort Erie Mayor Tom Insinna used provincial strong-mayor powers to dismiss Chief Administrative Officer Chris McQueen without cause less than 48 hours after taking office. Insinna intends to appoint Krystle Caputo, a special adviser at the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing, as the new CAO effective November 30. Corporate services director Jonathan Janzen will serve as the interim CAO until that date.
The decision has drawn criticism from several town councillors who cite a lack of a competitive recruitment process and question Caputo's municipal management experience. Caputo previously held roles with the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority and the ONpoint Strategy Group before returning to the provincial government in January 2026.
Ward 2 Councillor Nick Dubanow is seeking guidance from the integrity commissioner regarding the transparency of the hiring process. Ward 5 Councillor Tom Lewis criticized the mayor for excluding the council from meaningful discussion, arguing that the mayor used his powers to achieve a sole objective rather than building consensus.