ThinkPatternGet the app
Story
POLITICS · NOV 20, 2026

Minnesota Cities Use Coin Flips and Cards to Break Ties

Several Minnesota cities used random chance methods, including coin flips and card draws, to resolve deadlocked election results during the 2024 cycle.

Multiple cities across Minnesota utilized random chance to resolve deadlocked election results during the 2024 cycle, following state statutes that allow canvassing boards to determine tied contests by lot.

In Pine Island, a coin flip decided a City Council seat between incumbent Delana Weis and Dominick Pahl, with Weis winning after calling heads. Kettle River officials used a deck of cards, limited to ranks two through nine, to settle a council race won by Patricia Lundstrom. Other municipalities employed name-draws: Wrenshall used a hat to determine its mayor, and St. Francis used a bowl to break a mayoral primary tie.

Spring Lake Park initially settled a mayoral tie between Bob Nelson and Halyn Roth by drawing names from film canisters in a tote bag. However, a subsequent recount overturned the random result, declaring Roth the winner by a single vote. These local events align with a broader national pattern where 28 U.S. states permit random methods for legislative ties, while 12 states require new elections.


Reported across 16 outlets
Actors
Bob NelsonPatricia Lundstrom

Keep reading in the app

The full story and every source, free in the app.