State Farm Agrees to $45 Million Oklahoma Claims Settlement
State Farm will pay $45 million to settle allegations that it improperly denied or underpaid roof damage claims for Oklahoma homeowners.
The Oklahoma Insurance Department secured a $45 million settlement from State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. following an investigation into the company's handling of wind and hail roof damage claims. The probe, which began in May 2022, found that the insurer improperly denied or failed to pay for repairs for homeowners between 2021 and 2025. Internal documents suggested the company utilized a cost-lowering playbook in Oklahoma that had previously been used in Texas.
The settlement allocates at least $35 million to a claims review process conducted by an independent third party for eligible policyholders, $10 million to the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes grant program, and $2.86 million in fines and examination expenses. Some reports indicate different allocations, including $20 million for claims and $15 million for fines.
Outgoing Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready stated the investigation involved putting independent engineers in the field to ensure claims were handled appropriately. However, incoming Commissioner Bob Sullivan expressed concern that the agreement limits regulatory flexibility by preventing new market conduct examinations against the company for a period of 12 to 18 months.
State Farm disagreed with the findings and characterizations of the market conduct examination, citing $178.5 million in net underwriting losses in the state during the period in question. State Senator Andy Fugate criticized the settlement as insufficient, arguing it merely forces the company to perform duties it should have fulfilled initially.