ThinkPatternGet the app
Story
BUSINESS · NOV 17, 2026

Professional Financial Advisers Outperform DIY Investing in Market Downturns

Research from Morningstar and Vanguard shows professional financial advisers provide significant return advantages over DIY investing, particularly by preventing panic-driven decisions during market crashes.

Research from several investment firms indicates that professional financial advisers provide a significant advantage over do-it-yourself investing, especially during extreme market volatility. Morningstar, Inc. reports that managed accounts delivered an 18% advantage over DIY portfolios in worst-case scenarios, while The Vanguard Group estimates that professional guidance adds up to 3% in annual net returns.

Data from Aon and Financial Engines further supports this trend in retirement savings, showing that managed 401(k) options outpace DIY peers by 3.32% annually due to superior diversification. These gains are primarily attributed to the ability of advisers to prevent costly reactive decisions, such as selling at market lows or halting contributions during downturns, which often plague investors lacking emotional discipline or those who chase trends.

However, the benefits of professional management are not universal. A 2025 study by Morningstar found that only 38% of actively managed funds beat their passive peers, a result often driven by the drag of advisory fees. This suggests that while advisers provide critical emotional and strategic guardrails, the cost of management can offset gains in certain fund types.


Reported across 2 outlets
Actors
Morningstar, Inc.The Vanguard GroupAon

Keep reading in the app

The full story and every source, free in the app.