Scientists Sue NIH Over Alleged Viewpoint-Based Grant Censorship
Jade Pagkas-Bather and other researchers filed a First Amendment lawsuit against the NIH alleging the Trump administration is censoring scientific research through grant renegotiations.
A group of 14 plaintiffs, led by scientist Jade Pagkas-Bather, filed a First Amendment lawsuit against the National Institutes of Health (NIH), alleging the Trump administration is engaging in viewpoint-based discrimination. The lawsuit claims the government uses an opaque text analysis tool to flag and censor research that does not align with administration priorities, specifically targeting health equity research and the concept of gender as non-binary.
Dr. Pagkas-Bather alleges she was pressured to remove references to racial poverty disparities and gender identities from her HIV study. The NIH has defended these actions as a standard effort to replace subjective concepts with objective and measurable variables. The agency stated that more than 5,000 grants have been renegotiated to ensure the funding of the most meritorious science.
In a related legal development, the Supreme Court of the United States rejected a request from the Trump administration to revive cuts to tens of millions of dollars in research grants awarded to the University of California. This decision upholds a lower-court ruling that the administration likely violated the First Amendment by terminating grants based on the perceived viewpoints of researchers. The targeted research involved diversity, gender, and vaccine hesitancy. While the Justice Department intends to continue its legal fight over the executive branch's authority to administer federal funding, the funding for the affected University of California researchers remains in place.