Democrats Are Arguing Over Who Built the South They Just Won
The senators-elect who flipped the South by running against their own party now hold the deciding votes in the December 1 fight over who leads it — and every 2028 hopeful is already courting them.
Scott Colom spent the week after the biggest upset of the midterms refusing to let Washington claim him. Chuck Schumer's team had started describing the new Mississippi senator-elect — elected but not yet sworn in — as one of their own, a recruit built by the national operation. Colom has a different account of who recruited him.
You think I was listening to somebody that lives in Brooklyn when I was deciding to run for United States Senate? No, I listened to the people of Mississippi. — Scott Colom
And he was plain about whose direction he had not been taking.
It's not accurate to say he recruited me, though, because the people of Mississippi recruited me. — Scott Colom
The receipts mostly back his version. The national party spent almost nothing on his race; the win was built by local Black-led organizing — MS Votes, the People's Advocacy Institute, Mississippi United — and the turnout those groups drove [1][2]. The man disputing who built his victory holds one of the votes that will decide who runs his party. On December 1, Senate Democrats cast a secret ballot — a private vote, with no record of who chose whom — for the leader who will steer them against a Republican president. Ten days after that comes December 11, the deadline to fund the government. Squeezed between, on December 2, Jon Ossoff's Georgia runoff [3]. The shutdown date matters because the shutdown question is where this fight began. Schumer's March 2025 vote to end a government shutdown alienated the party's base and opened the rebellion — senators defying his candidate picks, a candidate declaring on stage that she wouldn't support him as leader. It broke the caucus for good in November 2025, when the longest shutdown in American history ended after the Republican leader John Thune cut Schumer out and dealt directly with rank-and-file Democrats; eight of them broke ranks, Ro Khanna called for Schumer's replacement, and David Axelrod predicted he would not be leading the party into 2027. That prophecy now goes to a vote. The challenger has made the old shutdown question his platform. Chris Van Hollen's bid rests on two demands: abolish the filibuster — the rule that lets a minority block most legislation — and defund the Iran war even if it triggers a shutdown [4].
the American people “want a Democratic Party that will stand up to powerful special interests, take on the billionaire class and fight for working families. That is why I am supporting Senator Chris Van Hollen to lead Senate Democrats. — Bernie Sanders
It is the same demand he, Sanders, Duckworth and Bennet have pledged to enforce at the December 11 deadline, by blocking any spending bill that doesn't ban Iran-war funding [5]. The audition is the platform, put on the record days before the vote. A rival faction wants the opposite — restoring the filibuster to its pre-2013 strength to force bipartisanship [6]. Both camps are claiming the same win, and both overreach. The day Van Hollen announced, 54 Sunrise Movement protesters were arrested outside Schumer's office, reading the blue wave as a mandate for confrontation — abolish the filibuster, replace the leadership [7].
Chuck Schumer doesn’t listen to us. He listens to corporate money, specifically coming from AIPAC. — Sunrise Movement
But the Southern seats were not won that way. Colom campaigned at a Trump rally and accepted the praise when Trump called it nerve; his closing argument was that he would put his state first [1]. James Talarico, the new Texas senator-elect, spent the fall moving toward the center on trans athletes and fossil fuels; Roy Cooper won North Carolina by running away from the national Democratic brand [8][9]. And Cooper is the complication — Schumer personally recruited him for that seat [10]. The Southern map has two authors, which is why neither camp can claim it outright. Schumer's people say he has the 55 votes to win December 1, with allies crediting him for the sweep [4]. And the challenge carries a price: John Fetterman has threatened to leave the party if Van Hollen wins, over his stance on Israel [4]. None of this is only about a Senate job. Kamala Harris, deciding whether to run again in 2028, has been courting the same movement and the same wing — the Uncommitted voters, the new Southern senators. She campaigned for Colom in Mississippi in October [11].
I am honored to have Vice President Harris join me on the campaign trail as we fight to lower costs for Mississippi families, raise the minimum wage, and save healthcare and our rural hospitals. — Scott Colom
Asked directly whether she'll run, she won't say.
I might. I might. I’m thinking about it… I’ll keep you posted. — Kamala Harris
Ossoff is working the same arithmetic from the other side — raising $77 million while his runoff lands the day after the leadership vote [3]. The man who insisted nobody recruited him is now the most courted recruit in his own party — by the leader he won't commit to, by the challenger who needs his vote, by the woman deciding whether to run for president. The people who built the South's biggest win did it by running away from Washington. Now Washington needs them to decide who runs it.
- 1. Scott Colom Wins Historic U.S. Senate Seat in Mississippi
- 2. Democrats Flip Key Southern Senate Seats and Governorships
- 3. Senator Jon Ossoff Positions for Re-election and 2028 Run
- 4. Chris Van Hollen Challenges Chuck Schumer for Senate Leadership
- 5. Democrats Threaten Government Shutdown to Defund Iran War
- 6. Chuck Schumer to Lead Senate Under President Donald Trump
- 7. Sunrise Movement Protesters Arrested at Chuck Schumer's Office
- 8. James Talarico Moderates Platform and Targets Black Voters in Texas
- 9. Democratic Senate Candidates Split Over Campaign Styles
- 10. Chuck Schumer Recruits High-Profile Candidates for 2026 Senate Races
- 11. Kamala Harris Courts Progressive Leaders Ahead of 2028 Bid