Letitia James Challenges Validity of Trump-Appointed Federal Prosecutors
New York Attorney General Letitia James is fighting federal subpoenas and mortgage fraud charges by challenging the legal appointments of the prosecutors leading the cases.
New York Attorney General Letitia James is challenging the legality of federal subpoenas and a criminal indictment, alleging the Trump administration is weaponizing the justice system for retaliation. In the Southern District of New York, James filed a motion to quash subpoenas issued by Acting U.S. Attorney John A. Sarcone III. These subpoenas seek documents regarding her civil fraud case against Donald Trump and her litigation against the National Rifle Association. James argues that Sarcone was improperly appointed by Attorney General Pam Bondi and lacks the authority to issue the requests.
Judge Lorna Schofield recently unsealed court documents related to the motion, stating the information was not secret, though she has not yet ruled on the validity of the subpoenas or Sarcone's appointment. This effort mirrors a separate legal battle in Virginia, where James pleaded not guilty to bank fraud and false statement charges related to a 2020 mortgage. Her legal team intends to challenge the appointment of prosecutor Lindsey Halligan on similar grounds to those used against Sarcone.
In the Virginia case, U.S. District Judge Jamar Walker denied a request by James's attorney, Abbe Lowell, to compel prosecutors to maintain a log of communications with the media. While Judge Walker called reports of Halligan using encrypted Signal messages "unusual," he ruled a log was unnecessary, though he did order a litigation hold to preserve records. The dispute occurs as President Trump has reportedly bypassed Senate confirmation to install loyalists in federal prosecutorial roles, a practice already ruled illegal in California.