European Commission Accused of Manipulating Egypt Loan Data
The European Commission faces accusations of sugarcoating Egypt's social welfare performance to justify releasing 2.5 billion euros in loans.
The European Commission is facing accusations of manipulating data to justify the release of 2.5 billion euros in soft loans to Egypt. The funding is part of a 7.4 billion euro strategic partnership established in 2024 between Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Egyptian President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi, which required Egypt to expand social welfare programs like the Takaful and Karama cash transfer initiatives.
Leaked documents and Egyptian government data suggest that instead of expanding coverage, there was a net reduction of 85,734 beneficiary households between 2024 and 2026. Despite this decline, the Commission reported the targets as fulfilled or broadly fulfilled. The Commission defended its assessment, stating that the targets referred to new beneficiary families rather than a net increase in the total number of recipients.
Members of the European Parliament have criticized the move, arguing that the Commission is prioritizing migration cooperation over human rights and socioeconomic conditions. Tineke Strik and Sandra Gómez López have demanded transparency, claiming the Commission has treated reporting obligations as an inconvenient formality while using financial assistance to lure Egypt into migration agreements.