Judge Blocks Trump HIV Funding Restrictions on Transgender Care
US District Judge William Young blocked Trump administration restrictions that barred federal HIV-treatment funds for providers offering gender-affirming care or acknowledging gender identity.
US District Judge William Young blocked the Trump administration from imposing restrictions on federal HIV-treatment funds that penalized healthcare providers for acknowledging the gender identity of transgender patients or providing gender-affirming care. The ruling follows a lawsuit filed by national medical associations, including the American Academy of HIV Medicine, which challenged conditions added to the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program.
The administration had used the Health Resources and Services Administration to enforce an executive order recognizing only two sexes. These conditions barred providers from using preferred pronouns or offering gender-affirming services if they wished to receive federal grants.
Judge Young ruled that the restrictions violated the First Amendment by penalizing doctors for their speech and the Fifth Amendment by discriminating on the basis of sex. He characterized the policies as being based in "animus, loathing, and discrimination," stating that they are contrary to national laws and cannot continue to stand.