ThinkPatternGet the app
Perspective
POLITICS · NOV 15, 2026

The Big Cases Are Dying of Their Own Fixes

The Justice Department's showcase prosecutions are collapsing one by one — and each one dies on a shortcut the department took to force the indictment through.

The department's showcase prosecutions have been dying this fall before any fact-finder ever weighs the evidence. Read the dismissals in a row and the striking thing is not that the cases fail but where they fail: each one collapses on a move the department itself made to lock the indictment in. The strangest is the Comey matter. One of the three prosecutions spun out of it was dismissed not for anything James Comey or his aides did, but on the prosecutor's own papers. Lindsey Halligan, the lawyer assigned to the case, held the job through an appointment that skipped Senate confirmation — a practice a California court had already ruled unlawful. [1][2] Halligan was there only because the prosecutors who first held the case had been cleared out the year before. And Daniel Richman, Comey's former aide, has told the court the department ran a harassment campaign to flip him into a witness against Comey — grand jury summons for the workers in his New York apartment building, threats of obstruction charges. That part is his allegation, not a finding; the dismissal needs no such finding, because it rests on the prosecutor's qualifications rather than the target's conduct. Hagan Scotten saw where this was headed. Scotten was one of the career prosecutors who resigned in October 2025 rather than pursue the cases the department demanded, and his resignation letter was blunt about what would come next.

I expect you will eventually find someone who is enough of a fool, or enough of a coward, to file your motion. — Hagan Scotten

The department found its filer. And it is the filers' qualifications, more than the targets' conduct, that the courts keep striking. Erik Siebert, the veteran prosecutor first assigned the case against New York Attorney General Letitia James, resigned rather than bring charges he said lacked evidence; a federal judge this fall ruled the 2025 firing of prosecutor Maurene Comey illegal. [3][4] The department's answer to each refusal was the same shortcut: put a loyalist in the post without Senate confirmation, and file. That shortcut produced exactly one headline indictment — the bank-fraud case against James, brought by a replacement prosecutor — and the replacement's appointment is now that case's contested flank, challenged in court alongside the other unconfirmed posts. [2] The jurors have jammed harder. In October, a federal grand jury empaneled to consider perjury charges against former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson declined to indict her — a no true bill, meaning the grand jurors themselves, not a judge, refused to authorize charges. [4] It was not the first refusal: in August 2025 a D.C. grand jury rejected the felony indictment against Alvin Summers after watching body-camera footage, following failed felony indictments against Sidney Reid and Sean Dunn in the same crackdown. [5] So the department routed around the grand jury. One workaround was to file a complaint — a charge a prosecutor brings without a grand jury's vote. Magistrate Judge Faruqui dismissed the complaint against two former FBI officials as political "weaponization," timed to the midterms, after testimony that FBI Director Kash Patel ordered the probe right after Trump's July election-security speech, and asked why the department had skipped the grand jury entirely. [6]

What has transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization — Zia Faruqui

The other workaround was to manage the jurors until they agreed. In the Broadview Six case — the prosecution of six people for a September 2025 protest at an ICE facility — Judge April Perry found prosecutors had removed grand jurors who disagreed with the government's case and contacted one juror outside court, and she dismissed every charge.

That trust has been broken. — April Perry

The matter did not end with that finding. This past week Perry ordered a hearing into whether the U.S. attorney's office concealed grand jury misconduct or pressure from Justice Department leaders in Washington to force the indictments — the live edge of this loop, now examining whether the pressure itself was hidden. [7] Even the bench gets the same treatment. In Minnesota, a chief judge found the government violated 210 immigration court orders, and the department answered by filing misconduct complaints against nearly every active district judge in the state. [8] None of this means the department has stopped. The jam is not a stop. The election-crime operation still runs cleanly against small targets: 63 new charges announced the week of November 3 pushed the total to 239, and the department indicted a Utah mail carrier who dumped 300 ballots in a church dumpster out of laziness. [9][10] New fronts open as fast as old ones close — the Southern Poverty Law Center indicted for fraud, county officials subpoenaed after the voter-data suits were dropped, the winners of the midterms themselves now under investigation. [11][12][13] The department's own defense, filed in support of the Comey and James indictments, was that the charging decisions "rested with department officials, not President Trump."

There is no direct admission of discriminatory purpose. — United States Department of Justice

The loop has reached an inversion worth naming. The questions now open in these courtrooms concern the department's own moves — who appointed the prosecutor, who skipped the grand jury, who leaned on the jurors — not the conduct of the people indicted. The process the department kept routing around is now examining the routes. And nothing is slowing: the investigations widen even as the cases collapse. The big prosecutions are simply dying of their own fixes.


Sources
  1. 1. Former FBI Aide Alleges DOJ Harassment in Comey Cases
  2. 2. Letitia James Challenges Validity of Trump-Appointed Federal Prosecutors
  3. 3. Federal Grand Jury Indicts New York Attorney General Letitia James
  4. 4. Department of Justice Faces Multiple Legal Setbacks in October
  5. 5. D.C. Grand Jury Rejects Felony Indictment Against Alvin Summers
  6. 6. Judge Dismisses Case Against Former FBI Officials Over Weaponization
  7. 7. Judge Orders Hearing on Prosecutor Conduct in Broadview Six Case
  8. 8. Trump Administration Clashes With Federal Judiciary Over Court Orders
  9. 9. Ninth Circuit Restores Block on Trump Election Probe
  10. 10. Justice Department Indicts Utah Postal Worker for Destroying Ballots
  11. 11. DOJ Indicts Southern Poverty Law Center for Donor Fraud
  12. 12. Trump Administration Targets California Voter Rolls With Subpoenas
  13. 13. Trump Orders DOJ Investigation After Democratic Congressional Sweep

Keep reading in the app

The full perspective, free in the app.