Washington Says Data Centers Should Pay for AI Power. It Keeps Paying Instead.
By statute and mandate Washington told data centers to bring their own power and cover their grid costs — while emergency coal orders, a $950 million coal rescue, federal loans, and public land quietly sent the bill to everyone else.
Nine coal units were supposed to go dark. Their owners had filed to retire them and wanted out; the federal government, invoking emergency authority under Section 202(c) of the Federal Power Act, ordered all nine to keep burning — over the owners' protests about the cost, and at the request of a coal trade group that asked Washington to intervene "to protect grid reliability against surging electricity demand" [1]. A federal appeals court has already thrown one of those orders out as an overreach. The government, in other words, sided with the fuel's advocates against the people who own the plants — the owners who had already booked the shutdowns and wanted to be rid of them — on behalf of an industry's appetite for electricity. In the same season, Washington was saying the opposite out loud. The House passed the Ratepayer Protection Act 417-3, which pushes state commissions to make data centers over 100 megawatts cover their full grid costs but stops short of requiring it — which is why consumer groups call it unenforceable [2]. The Senate voted 65-31 to shift roughly $35 billion of transmission costs onto data centers over the next decade [3][4]. FERC told six regional grid operators their large-load rules were unjust and unreasonable and ordered the tariffs rewritten so households stop carrying the cost [5]. And the president announced that data centers must build their own power [6].
Data centers now are mandated by me that they build their own electricity, so they’re not taking it from the grid. — Donald Trump
Not one of those instruments has moved a dollar. Two drivers run the split. One is politics: voters rejected data center expansion in 52 of 53 ballot measures last month [7], and the private-pays statutes are the response. The other is the race with China, which OpenAI has taken to calling an "electron gap" [8]. The Department of Energy holds both in one hand. Its transmission study says the grid needs roughly 4,000 miles of power line replaced every year to serve a demand surge it ties to AI data centers [9], and the agency has been explicit about who should pay.
The whole principle is that the data centers will pay for the infrastructure upgrades for their generation, not the families. — Katie Jereza
Its lending arm, in the same months, redirected federal loans into the generation and wires that surge requires: $26.5 billion to Southern Company, $3.26 billion to AEP Texas, $1.6 billion to DTE [10]. The FERC proceeding that ordered the cost-shift stopped is simultaneously expediting large-user connections to keep the United States ahead of China in AI [5][11]. The executed ledger, meanwhile, kept adding lines. $950 million in taxpayer money went to 24 coal plants, and Clean Air Act exemptions from toxic-pollution limits to 70 more — requested, the companies said, to keep the grid reliable [12].
It is ludicrous that our customers would have to cover the costs of a $500m investment for such a slight improvement to particulate matter capture. — NorthWestern Energy
Federal land was handed to data centers, a Nevada solar project replaced by one with no new environmental review [4]. The bill was already being paid before any of this year's debates. PJM's own accounting puts the added system cost of data center growth at $29.4 billion, and its capacity-auction price went from $28.92 to $269.92 per megawatt-day [13]. Household bills have risen in 13 states [8], and Virginia regulators testified that residential customers bore the largest share of one transmission project built to serve a data center [13]. NERC, to be clear, blames coal retirements rather than data centers for the strain [14] — but the emergency orders and the exemptions were requested and granted citing the AI surge, whatever the grid's other troubles. That is the context in which to read Sam Altman's letter to the White House this fall. The AI industry has spent the season asking Washington to guarantee what it will not finance itself [15].
Given the magnitude of what I expect A.I.’s economic impact to look like, the government should serve the role of "insurer of last resort." — Sam Altman
Call it a request to underwrite an underwriting that is already in force. The paperwork is new. The backstop is not — it is running today, on coal that was supposed to be off the grid.
- 1. Trump Administration Forces Coal Plants to Delay Retirements
- 2. House Passes Ratepayer Protection Act Targeting AI Data Centers
- 3. Senate Passes Bipartisan Energy Permitting Reform Act
- 4. Congress Debates Bill to End Data Center Grid Freeloading
- 5. FERC Orders Six Grid Operators to Reform Large Load Access
- 6. Trump Mandates Data Centers Build Own Power Sources
- 7. Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves Defends AI Data Center Expansion
- 8. OpenAI Urges Federal Support for $500 Billion Stargate Project
- 9. US Grid Needs Billions in Upgrades Amid AI Surge
- 10. Energy Department Redirects Billions to Baseload and Grid Projects
- 11. US Federal Regulators Order Faster Grid Connections for AI
- 12. Trump Administration Provides $950 Million to Save Coal Plants
- 13. Data Center Power Demand Drives US Grid Cost Debates
- 14. NERC Warns Data Center Growth Increases Winter Blackout Risks
- 15. AI Executives Seek Government Financial Guarantees to Sustain Growth