Two Countries at a Time
At one summit, ASEAN signed a legally binding digital pact and missed its security deadline — the region now commits two countries at a time.
In the last week, one building in Manila hosted two different institutions. With China's premier in the room, ASEAN signed the Digital Economy Framework Agreement, a legally binding region-wide pact covering data flows, payments, cybersecurity and artificial intelligence, designed so members can move at different speeds [1][2]. Singapore's deputy prime minister put the reason in a sentence.
This flexibility allows our ASEAN to be able to progress not at the slowest member, but to allow us to progress at our own pace. — Gan Kim Yong
The summit's other flagship item was the South China Sea Code of Conduct, and the same flexibility that makes the digital pact work is exactly why the code never had to arrive. Nine negotiation rounds pushed the draft past 80 percent under the Philippines' own chairmanship, the 2026 deadline lapsed anyway, and the parties have already agreed the code will be a voluntary platform for "managing differences rather than settling disputes" [3]. Where pace can vary, ASEAN binds. Where a member's patron is the threat, consensus goes silent. Two years of water-cannoning and ramming at Scarborough Shoal, Thitu Island and Second Thomas Shoal; live-fire drills; sanctions on Defense Secretary Teodoro; an October summons over what Manila called a "thinly veiled threat" of force. None of it drew a collective ASEAN response. Only Philippine deals with outside powers [4]. So the commitments moved next door, two countries at a time. Canada became the fifth nation with visiting-forces access to the Philippines, after the United States, Australia, Japan and New Zealand [5]. Japan's reciprocal-access agreement, the first standing for Japanese forces in the Philippines since the war, is now an explicit template, with Manila eyeing similar troop deals with France and New Zealand [6]. The Australia pact signed days before the summit, which the summit never mentions, is Teodoro's own measure: a hundred bureaucratic steps for any joint action, cut to ten [7]. India is selling BrahMos shore-based missiles Manila's envoy calls credible deterrence [8]. Vietnam signed separate 2027 defense plans with Laos and Cambodia [9]. Indonesia signed a US defense partnership and immediately insisted it is non-binding [10]. Australia's Pacific pacts require Vanuatu, Fiji and Papua New Guinea to notify Canberra before signing with anyone else [11]. ASEAN's own meetings now convene the room without running it. At October's defense ministers' gathering in the Philippines, Australia's deputy prime minister attended and affirmed the bloc sits at the core of his country's vision, while the operative business ran in minilateral sidebars on cyber, maritime security, training and defense infrastructure [12]. The pattern repeated in January, when the Philippines and China resumed their frozen dialogue in Cebu on the sidelines of a Code of Conduct officials' meeting, complete with their own bilateral "roadmap for dialogue" [13]. The institution supplies the corridors. The deals happen in them. "ASEAN centrality" now travels in every direction at once. Anwar Ibrahim, last year's chair, still means it.
The global order is fraying. — Anwar Ibrahim
But the same words carry opposite loads.
what 'ASEAN centrality' is wielded for
Beijing: Wang Yi urges the region to resist "external interference" and presses every party to finalize the code — the one channel Beijing can dilute by consensus, rather than bilateral pacts it cannot veto [14].
The pact-builders: The Quad voices its "recognition of ASEAN centrality" even as it builds its own architecture [15], and the Philippine foreign secretary, whose government is signing the bilateral spree, tells the same room it must move "as one" .
Committed to a free and open Indo-Pacific with a recognition of ASEAN centrality
If we do not move forward as one, we risk being pulled apart.
It now names the center while the real work happens away from it. None of this is the death of the institution. The economic channel to China is alive and deepening: a July energy-security agreement and the ASEAN-China free-trade upgrade [16][17]. What is leaving is one specific kind of trust, the belief that a room of ten can do the hard thing together. Next year the code passes to Singapore, already agreed to be voluntary, non-binding, and to manage a dispute rather than settle it, while the actual deterrence lives in a hundred two-sided instruments, none of which touches the argument at the center of the room [3].
- 1. Chinese Premier Li Qiang Visits Manila for ASEAN Summit
- 2. ASEAN Signs World's First Region-Wide Digital Economy Agreement
- 3. ASEAN and China Miss 2026 South China Sea Code Deadline
- 4. Philippines and China Tensions Escalate in South China Sea
- 5. Canada and Philippines Sign Status of Visiting Forces Agreement
- 6. Japan and Philippines Sign Historic Reciprocal Access Agreement
- 7. Philippines and Australia Sign Defense Pact to Bolster Deterrence
- 8. Philippines Ambassador Cites Indian Defense Ties as Deterrent Against China
- 9. Vietnam Signs Defense Pacts With Laos and Cambodia
- 10. Indonesia and US Sign Defense Pact Amid Airspace Dispute
- 11. Australia Secures Pacific Security Pacts to Curb Chinese Influence
- 12. Richard Marles Attends ASEAN Defence Ministers Meeting in Philippines
- 13. Philippines and China Resume Political Dialogue in Cebu City
- 14. Wang Yi Urges ASEAN to Resist External South China Sea Interference
- 15. ASEAN and Quad Ministers Meet in Manila on Regional Security
- 16. China and ASEAN Agree to Enhance Regional Energy Security
- 17. China and ASEAN Align Development Visions at 2025 Summit