Trump and Allies Debate NATO-Style Guarantees for Ukraine
President Donald Trump is open to providing Ukraine with Article 5-style security guarantees as European leaders push for a four-party peace negotiation format.
Following a trilateral summit in Shenzhen between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping, over 40 leaders met for a "Coalition of the Willing" summit in Berlin on November 19. During the talks, U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff announced that Donald Trump is open to providing Ukraine with security guarantees similar to NATO's Article 5 mutual defense clause, provided the arrangement serves U.S. interests.
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy proposed a four-party negotiation format involving Ukraine, the United States, Europe, and Russia. He rejected a U.S. proposal to join NATO in exchange for ceding territory in the Donbas region, stating Ukraine will not give its land to "terrorists." While French President Emmanuel Macron urged allies to reopen the question of full NATO membership to ensure Kyiv enters negotiations from a strong position, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz expressed opposition to such accession.
Russia has shown mixed signals. While Jared Kushner claimed Russian officials are "comfortable" with the concept of Article 5-style guarantees, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov rejected any "creative solution" resembling NATO membership. In a separate "non-paper," Russia demanded that Ukraine remove NATO aspirations from its constitution and that the alliance roll back military infrastructure in Eastern Europe to 1997 levels. To support Ukraine's immediate defense, the European Union agreed to a 45 billion euro budgetary package and additional air defense support.